The Case for Workplace Investigations in Alberta

Though workplace investigations aren’t specifically mandated by Alberta law, there are situations where you will need them to fulfill your legal obligations under occupational health and safety regulations, human rights legislation, or a Collective Agreement. A properly done investigation will be a key piece of evidence to defend against liability, helping address harassment, discrimination, and safety concerns while demonstrating due diligence. Whether conducted internally (by properly trained, impartial personnel) or by outside experts, a thorough investigation can help protect your organization, maintain or restore employee trust, and create essential documentation. Understanding the complete framework will strengthen your approach to workplace issues.

If you are working in a unionized environment, there are specific considerations, discussed here.

It is important to note that this applies to provincially-regulated employers.  If you are a federally-regulated employer in Alberta, there are different requirements under the Canada Labour Code and other federal legislation which are not addressed in this article.

Legal Framework for Workplace Investigations in Alberta

While Alberta doesn’t have specific legislation mandating workplace investigations, several legal frameworks create implicit requirements for employers to investigate workplace incidents.

You’ll find these obligations stemming from occupational health and safety laws, human rights legislation, and common law principles that establish your duty to provide a safe workplace.

Under Alberta’s Occupational Health and Safety Act, employers are obligated to address workplace hazards, which includes investigating reports of harassment or violence.

The Alberta Human Rights Act also creates an expectation that an employer will investigate complaints or claims of discrimination.

Additionally, your common law duty of care means you must take reasonable steps to protect employees from foreseeable harm, which often necessitates conducting thorough investigations when complaints, incidents, or near-misses occur.

Benefits of Third-Party Investigators

Given these legal frameworks, many organizations find significant value in bringing in outside investigators to handle workplace incidents. You’ll benefit from their objectivity, specialized expertise, and ability to maintain confidentiality throughout the process. Third-party investigators aren’t influenced by internal politics or relationships, which helps ensure fair and unbiased outcomes.

Benefits	Internal Investigators	External Investigators
Objectivity	May have biases	Completely neutral
Cost	Lower upfront cost	Better long-term value
Expertise	Limited experience	Specialized knowledge
Time	Splits focus with other duties	Dedicated attention
Legal Protection	Basic understanding	Enhanced defensibility

Maintaining professional distance between the employer and the investigator helps protect your organization from potential liability while demonstrating your commitment to fair treatment and due process. It’s an investment that often pays off by preventing costly mistakes and reducing legal risks.  Third-party external investigations are less likely to be challenged as biased or lacking impartiality, which helps increase employee confidence in the fairness of the process.

Key Steps in the Investigation Process

A successful workplace investigation must follow several essential steps to guarantee thoroughness, fairness, and legal compliance.

When you’re planning an investigation, you’ll need to carefully document each phase while maintaining confidentiality throughout the process.

The core steps of your investigation should include:

1. Receiving and evaluating the initial complaint to determine scope
2. Appointing an investigator and providing them with a clear mandate

The investigator is then responsible for:

• Gathering relevant evidence through interviews and document collection
• Analyzing the collected information against applicable policies
• Drawing conclusions based on the balance of probabilities
• Reporting their findings and providing rationale for their determinations

You’ll want to start by creating a clear investigation plan that outlines your approach, timeline, and key stakeholders.

Remember to secure all evidence promptly and conduct interviews in a structured manner that allows for thorough questioning while protecting the rights of all parties involved.  Ensure that you are in compliance with policies and that you are cognizant of any potential for bias that may be present.

Common Triggers for Workplace Investigations

Several specific situations trigger the need for workplace investigations, building on the structured investigation process outlined above.

You’ll need to investigate when:

• Employees report harassment, discrimination, or bullying behaviours that violate workplace policies or the law.
  • there are suspicions of theft, fraud, or misuse of company resources.
• There are reports or complaints of safety violations or unsafe working conditions (if these present imminent danger of serious harm, do not delay , and ensure you are in compliance with legislative reporting obligations).
• There are allegations of potential misconduct or policy violations,
• If there are any concerns about ethical breaches or conflicts of interest.

Role of Documentation and Evidence Gathering

Thorough documentation and evidence gathering serve as the foundation of any effective workplace investigation.

You’ll need to maintain detailed records throughout the investigation process to guarantee accuracy and protect your organization from potential legal challenges.

Key elements you should document include:

1. Written statements from complainants, respondents, and witnesses
2. Physical evidence like emails, text messages, or surveillance footage
3. Timeline of events and investigation activities
4. Interview notes and transcripts
5. Copies of policies, communications, or training materials related to the subject

It’s essential to store all documentation securely and you should organize evidence chronologically and keep a clear chain of custody for any physical items.

Remember to date and sign all documents, and make sure that electronic records are properly backed up and protected from unauthorized access.

All parties involved in an investigation must maintain confidentiality throughout the process.  Ensure breaches are promptly and consistently dealt with.d make sure that electronic records are properly backed up and protected from unauthorized access.

Rights and Responsibilities During Investigations

During workplace investigations in Alberta, both employers and employees have specific rights and responsibilities that must be carefully balanced to guarantee a fair process.

As an employer, you’re responsible for maintaining confidentiality, conducting timely investigations, and protecting participants from retaliation. You must also provide reasonable notice and allow employees to have representation present during interviews.

If you’re an employee involved in an investigation, you have the right to know the allegations against you, respond to these allegations, and present your evidence.

You’re required to cooperate with the investigation, maintain confidentiality, and provide truthful information. You shouldn’t discuss the investigation with coworkers or attempt to influence other witnesses’ testimonies. Remember that you’re protected from reprisal for participating in good faith.

Best Practices for Maintaining Confidentiality

Maintaining confidentiality in workplace investigations is essential to protect all parties involved and secure the integrity of the process.

You’ll need to implement strict protocols to make certain sensitive information doesn’t leak and potentially compromise the investigation’s effectiveness or damage reputations.

1. Communicate expectations clearly to all participants about their obligation to maintain confidentiality.
2. Store investigation documents in secure, password-protected locations with restricted access.
3. Use private meeting spaces for interviews and avoid discussing the investigation in common areas.
4. Redact identifying information when sharing necessary details with those who need to know.
5. Ensure that confidentiality agreements are clearly written, and signed by each participant.

Remember that breaches in confidentiality can lead to damaged workplace relationships, potential legal liability, and reduced employee trust in the investigation process.

It’s vital to document your confidentiality measures and enforce them consistently throughout the investigation.

Impact on Employee Relations and Culture

Workplace investigations can greatly shape employee relations and organizational culture long after their conclusion. When you handle investigations properly, you’ll demonstrate your commitment to fairness and accountability, which builds trust among your workforce. Your employees will feel more confident reporting concerns when they know you’ll address issues seriously and professionally.

However, poorly managed investigations, inconsistent practices or enforcement, or any perception of bias or influence can damage morale and create lasting divisions. You’ll need to balance transparency with confidentiality while maintaining clear communication throughout the process.

Risk Management Through Proper Investigations

Proper workplace investigations serve as a critical shield against various organizational risks, including potential legal liability, reputational damage, and employee relations issues.

When you conduct thorough investigations, you’re establishing a documented record of your company’s commitment to addressing workplace concerns professionally and fairly.

1. You’ll demonstrate due diligence in addressing complaints, which can protect your organization if legal action arises.
2. You’ll create a clear paper trail that shows you’ve taken reasonable steps to maintain a safe workplace.
3. You’ll identify potential systemic issues before they escalate into larger problems.
4. You’ll build employee trust by showing you take their concerns seriously.

Strengthening Your Investigation Protocol

To build a robust investigation protocol that withstands scrutiny, you’ll need to establish clear, systematic procedures that guide your organization through each step of the investigative process.

Start by creating standardized forms and templates for complaint intake, witness statements, and investigation reports.

You’ll want to define specific timelines for each investigation phase and establish criteria for determining when external investigators should be engaged.

Implement a documentation system that maintains confidentiality while ensuring accessibility for authorized personnel.

Don’t forget to incorporate regular training sessions for your HR team and managers on investigation techniques, interviewing skills, and evidence gathering. Your protocol should also include clear guidelines for communicating with all parties involved and a process for reviewing and updating investigation procedures annually.

Conclusion

While workplace investigations aren’t legally mandated in Alberta, they’re essential for protecting your business and employees. By investing in thorough investigation protocols, you’ll build trust, address misconduct effectively, and minimize legal risks. Remember to maintain confidentiality, document thoroughly, and consider third-party investigators when needed. Your commitment to proper investigations demonstrates leadership and creates a safer, more productive workplace for everyone.

PRIVACY NOTICE:  Any information you provide to our office — whether your personal information or employment/employer details — will be treated as strictly confidential and will not be disclosed to your employer or to any other third party. So, please be reassured that you can talk openly to our capable Intake Paralegals worry free. Fill out an Online Inquiry or call us now, your information will be in safe and helping hands.

The Legal Review Process by Taylor Janis Workplace Law

• Taylor Janis strives for high-quality, legally verified content.
• Content is meticulously researched and reviewed by our legal writers/proofers.
• Details are sourced from trusted legal sources like the Employment Standards Code.
• Each article is edited for accuracy, clarity, and relevance.
• If you find any incorrect information or discrepancies in legal facts, we kindly ask that you contact us with a correction to ensure accuracy.