Case commentary: Kosteckyj v Paramount Resources Ltd, 2021 ABQB 225
Constructive Dismissal Due to COVID-19
In the recent case of Kosteckyj v Paramount Resources Ltd, the Court of Queen’s Bench of Alberta found that the employer’s reduction in employee remuneration – including a salary reduction, suspension of RRSP contributions and a delay or cancellation of a bonus program, which were all done as part of a cost-cutting measure due to COVID-19 – amounted to a constructive dismissal of the employee.
The Court followed the test for constructive dismissal set out in Potter v New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10, where a court must ascertain whether the employer has unilaterally changed the contract.
It found that when the company imposed its cost reduction program, this amounted to a unilateral change by the employer as there was no evidence that the employee had ever agreed, explicitly or impliedly, to those remuneration reductions.
It was further determined that those changes amounted to a reduction in Ms. Kosteckyj’s compensation in the range of 16.65% to 20%.
Considering the above, as well as having regard to the fact that the company terminated a 47-year-old professional engineer in the middle of an economic downturn, the Court awarded Ms. Kosteckyj, who had provided 6.5 years of service to the company, with 9 months of notice.
Interestingly, and of great importance in the current downturn in the Alberta oil and gas sector, the Court commented as follows: “I find that it is appropriate to consider, as one of the factors, the current challenges for the oil and gas sector which both parties agree exist.”
This case serves to highlight the significant obligations employers owe to their employees even during, and in some regards particularly due to, the current economic downturn the province finds itself in.
An employer cannot simply unilaterally change an employee’s contract without risking the change amounting to a constructive dismissal of their employee, which warrant damages as if the employee were in fact terminated without just cause.